Connect with us

NEWS

Europe Sits Outside as Ukraine and Russia Swap Prisoners

Russia and Ukraine agreed a large prisoner swap in Abu Dhabi, with European envoys kept outside the room as U.S. mediators carried that fight to Putin.

Published

on

U.S. envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff reached the Kremlin on Thursday, November 12, after Russia and Ukraine agreed in principle to a large prisoner exchange.

The two-day talks in Abu Dhabi, the first in nine months, produced no deal on land or on the security rules that would follow a ceasefire. European officials had flown to the same city and never entered the room.

Both Sides Can Swap Prisoners Without Europe in the Room

A prisoner list is the rare file Moscow and Kyiv still move while the war runs. It does not require NATO on the paper, a European signature, or an answer on the Donbas line. Territory and the postwar security rules do, which is why those files stayed open after Tuesday and Wednesday in the United Arab Emirates.

Kushner, President Donald Trump’s son-in-law and a U.S. envoy, told reporters the sides had agreed on the biggest humanitarian release of prisoners of the nearly five-year full-scale war, with the numbers to be finalized on Thursday. Rustem Umerov, head of Ukraine’s foreign intelligence service and Kyiv’s lead in the room, said the main result was a large-scale exchange and that the details were still being worked out. Vladimir Medinsky, the Kremlin aide who led Russia’s delegation, called it a fundamental agreement in principle and said the figures would come later.

Kushner put the same claim on X after the session, presenting the swap as a way to reunite families and build trust after talks he described as serious, detailed, and frank.

He also said significant differences remain and that Washington wants broader talks that include European partners. That is the tell. The prisoner file closed in a three-way room. The file that would actually end the fighting is the one Europe was not allowed to touch.

Lavrov Told European Envoys to Sit in the Hotel

Sergey Lavrov, Russia’s foreign minister, was in Moscow, not Abu Dhabi, when he dismissed the European trip on Tuesday, November 10. He did not bother with process language.

As for the participation of the Europeans, well, they flew to Abu Dhabi. Let them sit there in the hotel.

Sergey Lavrov, Russian foreign minister, Moscow press conference

The slight was logistical and political at once. Senior Europeans were in the capital for the round and met Ukraine and the United States on the sidelines. They did not sit with Medinsky. After the talks, Medinsky said the Russian side had no contact with them and did not see what their trip had been for. He later told reporters Moscow had not received a single peace proposal from European countries and did not understand what there was to talk about with them.

Lavrov’s other complaint was more specific. He said everything coming from Brussels and other EU capitals amounted to a demand for an immediate ceasefire, after which Europe would move stabilization forces onto land still held by Kyiv. EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas had already rejected the premise, saying Europe already has its security rules in place, that Russia keeps breaking the treaties under them, and that Vladimir Putin does not have a veto over European security.

THE EUROPEAN TEAM IN ABU DHABI

  • The Commission: Björn Seibert, chief of cabinet to European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, led the EU side with Anna-Maria Boura, foreign policy adviser to European Council President António Costa.
  • NATO’s man: Geoffrey van Leeuwen, chief of staff to Secretary General Mark Rutte, represented the alliance.
  • The capitals: National security advisers from France, Germany, and the United Kingdom travelled with Italy, including Günter Sautter for Chancellor Friedrich Merz, Jonathan Powell for the United Kingdom, and Fabrizio Saggio for Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni.

Participants in a coordination meeting ahead of trilateral talks said any future deal must respect Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity, offer credible security guarantees, and keep NATO central to collective defense. They also said they wanted the process to widen into multilateral talks. Moscow had already said this round would stay three-way.

One European Voice Is the Price of a Wider Table

Kushner said one of his aims in Moscow was to find a way to get Europeans added to the format. He was blunt about the other half of that problem, which sits in Brussels as much as in the Kremlin.

If Europe could identify one person to speak on their behalf, that would be a bigger achievement than getting the Russians to include them in the negotiations.

Jared Kushner, U.S. envoy, Abu Dhabi briefing

That line treats a union of 27 governments as a staffing issue. It also admits the order of power in this process. Washington is asking Putin to bless a wider table, and asking Europe to compress itself into a single chair before that ask can even be used. A German government spokesman said the U.S. pledge of European involvement would now be put to Putin, that Europe would take part in future talks, and that Berlin was waiting for a response. The same spokesman said European and U.S. negotiators had agreed in Abu Dhabi on a no-surprise policy, with no side deals and closer coordination going forward.

Medinsky, speaking to Russian television, said Moscow’s aim is a new, modern Yalta, the 1945 meeting at which Western leaders and the Soviet Union divided Europe. Ukraine has warned against that reading. Russia is still demanding that Kyiv pull its forces out of the parts of the eastern Donbas it still holds, and Medinsky told Russian journalists that every foot of soil would be returned to Russia, one way or another. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Ukraine will not give up occupied land for a settlement. Kyiv wants a ceasefire before any talk of territory. Putin has ruled out a direct meeting with Zelenskyy.

Kushner said there is no trust between the sides after a war like this, and that some areas look open to compromise while others need more discussion. He called Abu Dhabi a good first step. The step that would change the map is the one that still needs Europe in the chair, and the chair is empty until Moscow says it is not.

What Numbers Are on the Table for This Exchange?

The headcount is not fixed. Zelenskyy said on the first day that the sides had discussed a 1,000-for-1,000 exchange, and possibly 1,500-for-1,500. In Dublin he spoke of 1,000 or 1,200 captured soldiers from each side. Alexander Zorin, a deputy chief in the Russian General Staff’s information department who attended the talks, said the swap would be one of the biggest since 1,000 soldiers from each side went home last year, that it would involve more than 1,000 people on each side, and that it could happen in the next two or three weeks.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The deal: Russia and Ukraine agreed in principle on November 11 to a large prisoner exchange, confirmed by Umerov, Medinsky, and Kushner.
  • The range: Zelenskyy said the formats discussed were 1,000-for-1,000 or 1,500-for-1,500; his later public estimate was 1,000 or 1,200 from each side.
  • The timing: Zorin said the transfer could take place in the next two or three weeks, with numbers still being matched.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • The final list: Kushner said the numbers would be finalized on Thursday, November 12. No public headcount had been issued when the U.S. team reached the Kremlin.
  • The European seat: Kushner took the request for a wider format to Putin. There was no public answer from the meeting as the motorcade went in.
  • A leaders’ round: Kyiv still wants Zelenskyy and Putin in the same room. Putin has already said no.

Wartime swaps sit outside the default rule in the Third Geneva Convention on prisoners of war, which says captives are to be sent home without delay after fighting stops. While the war is on, each exchange is a separate bargain. That is why this file can move when the map cannot.

Istanbul’s 1,000-for-1,000 Swap Did Not Slow the War

Abu Dhabi is repeating a pattern the two sides already know. In Istanbul on May 16, 2025, they also failed to agree a ceasefire and still closed a 1,000-for-1,000 exchange, then the largest of the war. It ran over three days. On May 23, 390 Ukrainians came home, 270 of them military and 120 civilians. Another 307 service members returned on May 24. The last 303 came back on May 25.

The bombing did not wait on those buses. Heavy Russian drone and missile strikes hit Ukrainian cities during the same three days. The political talks stayed stuck on land. Prisoner swaps kept going anyway, because families and staff officers can trade names without settling NATO, Donbas, or Europe’s seat.

THE RECENT SWAP LEDGER

Round When it closed Each side Status
Istanbul 1,000-for-1,000 Agreed May 16, 2025; carried out May 23-25, 2025 1,000 Completed
Latest completed swap October 23, 2026 270 Completed
Abu Dhabi deal Agreed in principle November 11, 2026 1,000 to 1,500 discussed Numbers not fixed

The October 23 transfer brought 270 people back to Ukraine, 261 of them military and nine civilians, with the same number sent the other way. It was the 11th reported prisoner exchange of 2026. On November 2, Zelenskyy said more than 9,500 people brought home since the full-scale invasion began, including 1,596 this year. Those returns are real for the people on the lists. They have not moved the front, and they have not opened the door Lavrov ordered shut.

Zelenskyy Wants Specifics Back From Moscow in Dublin

Zelenskyy arrived in Dublin late on Wednesday for the ninth European Political Community meeting, with about 50 leaders due in the Irish capital on Thursday and an informal EU gathering set for Friday, November 13. He met Irish Prime Minister Micheál Martin and Lithuanian President Gitanas Nausėda, and he is due to see Kushner and Witkoff after they leave Moscow.

He gave the prisoner plan a muted welcome and then drew the line the U.S. team cannot blur. Ending this war without Europe’s participation, he said, would be unjust, and it would be impossible. He also said there had been a change in temperature, with Washington warmer to a European role. In Dublin he spoke of a window of opportunity, with the people now in the process wanting a result before 2027, while adding that he remained sceptical. What mattered, he said, was that the Americans had flown to Putin with specifics, and that he wanted them to return to Dublin with specifics.

David Arakhamia, the parliamentary leader of Zelenskyy’s party on the Ukrainian team, said really big progress had been made on issues he could not yet discuss and called for another round soon. He also spoke of hope for movement by the end of the year. Medinsky said he felt the talks helped Moscow and Kyiv edge closer to peace. Kremlin adviser Yuri Ushakov called them substantive and quite useful. Peskov, the Kremlin spokesman, said European representatives could join later but that their current statements do not show any desire to help along the path toward peace.

THE SHUTTLE AFTER ABU DHABI

  1. November 10, 2026: Four-hour three-way session opens in Abu Dhabi. Lavrov tells European envoys to sit in the hotel. EU, NATO, and E3 officials hold sideline meetings only.
  2. November 11, 2026: Talks run just under two hours and close with an agreement in principle on a large prisoner exchange. Kushner and Witkoff say they will take the file to Putin, then to Zelenskyy.
  3. November 12, 2026: The U.S. motorcade arrives at the Kremlin shortly after 1 p.m. local time. The envoys are then due in Dublin to brief Zelenskyy.
  4. November 13, 2026: Informal EU talks in Dublin are due to take up how Europe should be represented if the table ever widens.

Russia’s foreign ministry posted as the Kremlin meeting began.

Kushner had said the Moscow stop would go over what was discussed in Abu Dhabi and look for openings, because he saw some opportunities. Zelenskyy, waiting in Ireland, had already said a lot would depend on the American-Russian conversation. The European seat was on that agenda. So were the names on a prisoner list that still had no public total.

Fighting Did Not Pause for the Abu Dhabi Talks

The war did not freeze for the cameras in the Emirates. A daytime strike on a market in the southern Odesa region killed three people and injured 11, according to local authorities. Overnight strikes on the Zaporizhzhia region and the eastern city of Kharkiv wounded seven civilians. Russia said it downed 627 Ukrainian drones overnight, 150 of them over the region around St. Petersburg, and regional officials said drones started a fire at the port of Ust-Luga, a main facility for Russian oil exports, injuring three workers.

By Thursday, as the U.S. team entered the Kremlin, a Russian strike on a residential building in Kyiv had killed one person. Zelenskyy also said fresh limits had been placed on the Starshield satellite internet service that Ukrainian units use at the front, after a row with Trump last month over a deal to buy Russian diesel. Grid attacks have become the background noise of every diplomatic round, including strikes on Ukrainian energy sites after that diesel dispute, and the strikes that followed earlier energy truce talks.

Medinsky said security issues sat at the core of the Abu Dhabi meeting, including guarantees not only for Ukraine but for Russia once the fighting stops, and that one country’s protection must not come at the expense of the other’s. Kushner said Russia’s security concerns were discussed and that Moscow was told it needed de-escalation ideas Europe could accept. EU officials have said they see no need to reopen Europe’s wider security arrangements with Moscow before a ceasefire. That is the argument the people in the hotel were there to make, and it is the argument the three-way room did not have to hear.

Kushner and Witkoff were inside the Kremlin on Thursday afternoon with the prisoner file in hand and the European seat still empty. In Dublin, Zelenskyy was waiting for them to come back with specifics.

Harry is the editor of RTD JOURNAL, an independent publication that he owns, and ten years of journalism, first as a reporter, now as an editor, have left him with a habit of reading the documents other people skip. Annual reports are read to the footnotes, court filings to the exhibits, government releases to the methodology section, because that is where the numbers that matter usually sit. Each figure that reaches the page is checked against the document it came from, and claims that cannot be tied to a primary source are left out. That approach runs across the site's ten sections, written for an international readership: news, business and technology on one side, science, sports, entertainment, travel, lifestyle, gaming and auto on the other, all held to the same standard of evidence. A mistake, once found, is fixed on the article with a dated note that explains the change, as the site's public corrections policy requires. Readers can reach him with documents, questions or corrections at support@rtdjournal.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending