Connect with us

NEWS

Dublin Hosts 50 Leaders as Envoys Sit With Putin

Fifty leaders meet in Dublin as US envoys see Putin, leaving Europe still without a named seat at the talks.

Published

on

Fifty leaders are meeting in Dublin on Thursday, November 12, as US envoys sit down with Vladimir Putin in Moscow. The ninth European Political Community summit is the largest gathering of international leaders Ireland has ever hosted.

Jared Kushner said one aim in the Kremlin is to get Europeans added to peace talks that still have no EU seat.

50 Leaders Fill a Hall Putin Will Not Enter

Taoiseach Micheál Martin is hosting the session at the Convention Centre under the theme of a strong, secure and connected Europe. The Department of the Taoiseach listed 50 leaders at Dublin’s Convention Centre, among them Volodymyr Zelenskyy, UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, French President Emmanuel Macron, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen is in the room, as is Belarusian opposition leader Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya. Turkey’s president is at the COP31 climate summit. Belgium’s prime minister is tied up in budget talks at home.

Martin co-chairs with European Council President António Costa. Zelenskyy is one of only three leaders set to address the opening plenary, after Martin and before Costa. He landed on Wednesday, November 11, his third visit to Ireland in 12 months, and told Martin he was grateful for “unwavering support for our people, for Ukraine, for our defense.” Martin said he had restated Ireland’s backing for a country that “continue[s] to experience barbaric attacks.”

THE DUBLIN ROOM

  • The bill: The Department of the Taoiseach called this the biggest gathering of international leaders Ireland has ever hosted, the ninth EPC meeting since the forum was set up in 2022.
  • The staff: More than 2,000 people are working the Convention Centre operation, with a dinner later at the National Gallery of Ireland.
  • The guard: Some 700 Defence Forces personnel are on Operation Fianna from Wednesday through the early hours of Saturday, the largest security operation in the history of the state.
  • The Friday session: EU leaders hold an informal European Council on November 13, with Ukraine and the talks on the agenda.

The EPC is an informal table for EU and non-EU governments, not a defence alliance and not a place that can issue orders to NATO. That is the point of the guest list, and also its limit. A Friends of Ukraine grouping, co-hosted by the UK and Ukraine, is meeting on the margins, where Zelenskyy is expected to brief partners on two days of talks in Abu Dhabi that ended on November 11.

Moscow First, Then a Debrief in Dublin

Steve Witkoff and Kushner, who is President Donald Trump’s son-in-law, landed at Vnukovo in wet snow and were met by Kirill Dmitriev, Putin’s special envoy. They went on to the Kremlin for Witkoff’s 10th in-person meeting with Putin. After that they are due in Dublin to brief Zelenskyy, who told partners he wanted them back with more than atmosphere.

Abu Dhabi on November 10 and 11 was the first direct, US-mediated contact between Russian and Ukrainian negotiators since February. The war is in its fifth year. The sides agreed in principle on a large prisoner exchange that could come in the coming weeks. They did not announce a ceasefire, a map, or a security deal. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said no contacts with any EU representatives “were planned, and none took place.”

THE 72-HOUR ITINERARY

  1. November 10: US, Russian and Ukrainian teams open two days of talks in Abu Dhabi, the first such round in nine months.
  2. November 11: The round ends with a prisoner-swap plan and no public breakthrough on land. Zelenskyy arrives in Dublin and meets Martin. Kushner says he will ask Putin to let Europeans into the next round.
  3. November 12: Witkoff and Kushner meet Putin in Moscow, then fly to Ireland. Martin opens the EPC. Zelenskyy addresses the plenary and waits on the American debrief.
  4. November 13: EU leaders hold their informal European Council in Dublin, with Ukraine again on the paper.

The stop order is the map. Moscow in the morning, Dublin at night, Europe as the briefing after the Kremlin rather than the room where terms are set. Kushner told reporters the Moscow session would go over Abu Dhabi and look for “openings,” then “fly to Dublin” to sit with Zelenskyy. Zelenskyy, arriving in Ireland, put it more sharply: the Americans had gone to Putin “with specifics,” and he wanted them “to return to Dublin with specifics.”

No European Envoy, and Putin Holds the Blessing

Europe has not named a single negotiator for the US-led track. Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov said as much on Thursday. Merz, asked in Dublin about a European envoy, waved the personnel question away. “It’s not about individuals; what matters is that Putin is prepared to hold talks,” he said. Macron said Europe still needed “a clear and united vision of what it wants for Ukraine.”

I believe that hopefully tomorrow in Moscow, Steve (Witkoff) and I will be successful, and President Putin will give the blessing for that to occur.

Jared Kushner, US envoy, speaking on November 11 about adding Europeans to the talks

That is the strangeness Zelenskyy flagged to the plenary. He said Kyiv finds the US approach of discussing a new security order with Russia “weird,” and he urged European leaders to watch those talks closely. Costa argued there was no need to build an entirely new security arrangement, saying Russia had already torn up the one that existed by invading Ukraine. Zelenskyy did note a warmer American tone on Europe’s inclusion, after weeks in which Kyiv and several EU capitals feared a White House-Kremlin channel that left them outside.

Christoph Meyer, a professor of European and international politics at King’s College London, has said European leaders “cannot decide who has the authority to speak on behalf of Europe or to create adequate structures to feed into such an authority.” Last month Finnish President Alexander Stubb and Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre disclosed phone contact with Putin and drew a public rebuke from Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen, who said she was “very skeptical” and doubted that direct contact with the Kremlin would deliver much. The split is not a sideshow. It is why Kushner is asking a Russian president to bless a European chair.

Fridge Hacks, Flight Hoaxes and Blood Banks

Leaders are not only talking about a war in its fifth year. They are talking about a run of incidents that fall into the wide bucket of hybrid activity, the grey-zone operations short of war that European agencies now treat as a standing campaign. No state has been formally accused of ordering the bomb hoaxes that hit aviation and newsrooms. France has named Iran for the October supermarket hacks. Estonia and Germany have named Russia for earlier sabotage on their soil. Moscow says Europe pins “technical failures, infrastructure faults and criminal incidents” on Russia “without evidence.”

THE NOVEMBER DISRUPTION LEDGER

Incident Date Where Who officials named
Hoax bomb threats on passenger flights November 2 to 6 More than 50 flights; nearly 30 on November 5 No state formally accused
Hoax bomb threats to newsrooms November 6 Several European outlets None named
Threatening emails to schools November 11 Ireland, the UK and Italy Treated as hoaxes
Supermarket fridge cyberattack October 11 to 12 Hundreds of French stores France named the IRGC
Second fridge-temperature wave Early November Belgium, Luxembourg, Sweden, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Estonia, the Netherlands, Finland Pro-Russian hacktivists claimed the later wave
Attempt on blood-plasma refrigeration After the October hacks Three French sites Intrusion spotted in time; products held
Explosive-laden drone at Leipzig airport August 4 Germany, near Antonov aircraft Berlin named Moscow; Russia denied it
Fire at a drone-supply site September Tallinn Estonia named Russian special services

French Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot summoned Iran’s ambassador and said he could “confirm that responsibility for this act lies with the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps.” Hackers in the later wave pushed connected fridges as high as 50C, and stores including Carrefour, IKEA, Ahold Delhaize and Colruyt dumped food. Thirteen SuperValu shops in Ireland were among those hit. The same toolkit reached French plasma stores; monitors caught the intrusion before the stock was lost.

Gen. Alexus Grynkewich, NATO’s top commander in Europe, told European Parliament lawmakers in late September that the alliance was seeing a “quantitative and qualitative increase” in Russian hybrid activity and that “state-directed sabotage is growing increasingly brazen.” Denmark’s military and foreign intelligence service said in the same stretch that Moscow had “become more willing to take risks,” and that future hits could include cyberattacks that cripple basic services and sabotage with a high risk of casualties.

Why the Eastern Flank Absorbs Most of the Hits

The Dublin guest list is continent-wide. The damage is not. Security firm Osavul, which sells hybrid-risk intelligence to governments and is one of three technology providers on NATO’s information-environment assessment work, found that eight EU countries bordering Russia, Belarus or Ukraine took 60 percent of recorded hybrid incidents while holding just 18% of the EU’s population.

OSAVUL’S HYBRID OUTLOOK

  • The weight: Those eight border states account for 60% of the incidents Osavul logged, against 18% of EU residents.
  • The shift: Aviation was none of the Russian-linked incidents Osavul recorded in 2022 and 2023, then 19% in 2024 and 50% across 2025 and 2026.
  • The cut-outs: About 95% of identified perpetrators are “gig saboteurs,” civilians recruited online and paid to act, rather than career officers.
  • The miss rate: Roughly one-third of the covert incidents in its database were broken up before they caused damage.

Dmytro Plieshakov, Osavul’s co-founder and chief executive, said the pattern is “a concerning shift to fewer attacks but on bigger targets,” with aviation, trains, defence plants and energy now more likely than warehouse arson, “possibly with a risk to life.” John Foreman, a former British defence attaché in Moscow and Kyiv, has argued that “the lack of coordination between countries leaves seams and gaps which Russia exploits.” The eastern flank lives in those seams. Dublin is a long way from them, which is why the 60% figure sits badly beside a plenary that also has to talk competitiveness, energy and AI.

Von der Leyen said in September that sabotage, arson, cyberattacks and drone incursions “are ramping up every day,” and that as the threat climbs, “so must Europe’s preparedness.” She called for a European counter-hybrid playbook and for a consultation habit modelled on NATO’s Article 4 consultation process, the clause that lets any ally demand a meeting of the North Atlantic Council. “I believe it is time for Europe’s own Article 4,” she said, tying that to a European Security Council. The EU already has a hybrid toolbox of diplomatic and economic measures. It does not have NATO’s mutual-defence reflex, and Ireland, the host, is not in NATO at all.

A Neutral Capital Under Its Largest Security Net

Martin said on October 27 that Ireland “has no intention of joining NATO” and that the state is “militarily neutral.” He was answering former president Michael D. Higgins, who had warned that dropping the UN arm of the Triple Lock could slide Ireland toward military alliances. The government is still pushing a bill to end the need for a UN mandate before Irish troops go abroad, a fight that will run through the Oireachtas while this summit is in town. Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald pointed at Rutte’s presence in Dublin as proof of “greater militarisation” and “even closer alignment with Nato.”

The security plan treats the city as if the threat is already here. Gardaí locked down the docklands. Bridges are closed, airspace is restricted, and officers from Northern Ireland have been sent south to help. Irish naval ships took station off the coast even though they have no air-defence radar against drones. A foreign air-defence ship is posted outside territorial waters, a model used for earlier Irish EU events this year and widely described as a French frigate. Planners drew on last year’s EPC in Denmark, when Copenhagen Airport shut after suspected drone sightings.

RACO, the officers’ association, said senior ranks leading the joint task force from McKee Barracks were being asked to run counter-drone, maritime and explosive-ordnance work without the allowances paid to Garda equivalents, a row the Department of Defence moved to ease on the eve of the summit for commandants on 24-hour duty. The argument is local. The picture is not: a country that will not join NATO is using its largest-ever military and police deployment, plus a borrowed air-defence ship, to protect a summit about European security while the actual bargaining runs through Moscow.

Hoax bomb emails went to hundreds of schools in Ireland, the UK and Italy on Wednesday morning, after the aviation scares and the SuperValu fridge failures. The host is on the target list in miniature. That does not make Dublin an eastern-flank capital. It does mean the “secure” in the summit theme is not a slogan for somewhere else.

Zelensky Asked Them to Come Back With Specifics

Zelenskyy said on Wednesday there was a “window of opportunity” to reach peace before 2027, then added that he was still “sceptical.” He wanted results by the end of this year and said a lot would depend on the tone Witkoff and Kushner struck with Putin. On his own account he has about 20 leader meetings packed around the plenary. He also said the US approach to a new security order with Russia was “weird,” a warning aimed as much at the Europeans in the hall as at the Americans still in the air.

Rutte, speaking as Martin opened the session, said there had been “positive news” out of Abu Dhabi and that Ukraine needed to be “as strong as possible in this fight.” Burnham is expected to add further UK sanctions on Russia. Those are the instruments Europe actually holds: money, weapons, sanctions, political noise. They are not a chair in the room Kushner described, the one that still needs a blessing from the man Witkoff has now met ten times.

Martin will feed the leaders at the National Gallery tonight. The American debrief with Zelenskyy is due the same evening. Friday’s informal Council is the EU-only sequel, the place von der Leyen’s security-council idea might get another airing, or might not. Putin will not be in either room. The 50 leaders will talk about a strong, secure and connected Europe, then wait to hear what was said in the Kremlin.

Harry is the editor of RTD JOURNAL, an independent publication that he owns, and ten years of journalism, first as a reporter, now as an editor, have left him with a habit of reading the documents other people skip. Annual reports are read to the footnotes, court filings to the exhibits, government releases to the methodology section, because that is where the numbers that matter usually sit. Each figure that reaches the page is checked against the document it came from, and claims that cannot be tied to a primary source are left out. That approach runs across the site's ten sections, written for an international readership: news, business and technology on one side, science, sports, entertainment, travel, lifestyle, gaming and auto on the other, all held to the same standard of evidence. A mistake, once found, is fixed on the article with a dated note that explains the change, as the site's public corrections policy requires. Readers can reach him with documents, questions or corrections at support@rtdjournal.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending