Connect with us

NEWS

A Second Crash Exposes Spain’s Oldest High-Speed Line

A Renfe train hit a stopped Iryo near Urda, killing 69. It is the second deadly crash this year on a line still waiting for new signalling.

Published

on

A Renfe high-speed train struck a stopped Iryo service near Urda on October 28, killing 69 people on the Madrid-Seville line. It was the second deadly crash this year between the same two operators on the same corridor.

The line still uses the signalling fitted when it opened in 1992. Adif awarded a contract in 2021 to replace that system by early 2026. The new kit is not in service.

Rear-End Collision at Kilometre 118

Iryo train 6076 left Madrid Puerta de Atocha at 7:54 a.m. for Seville Santa Justa with 147 passengers, including one infant. Renfe AVE 2080, a Siemens Velaro, left at 8:00 a.m. on the same route with 397 passengers. Castilla-La Mancha spokeswoman Esther Padilla put the combined load at 544 passengers.

At 8:30 a.m. the LZB train-protection system failed on a 63-kilometre stretch around Urda. Six trains stopped automatically. Control passed to Adif’s 24-hour centre at Atocha. At 8:36 a.m. that centre told the AVE to start again at normal speed. The Iryo was still standing at a red signal at the entrance to Urda station.

The AVE covered about 25 kilometres in 17 minutes and hit the Iryo at 8:53 a.m. at kilometre 118, between Urda and Los Yébenes in Toledo province. Transport Minister Óscar Puente said the speed may have reached 200 km/h. The last three cars of the Iryo went down an embankment. The AVE’s locomotive left the track on the other side, and the first coach split.

THE 23 MINUTES AT URDA

  1. 7:54 a.m.: Iryo 6076 leaves Atocha for Seville.
  2. 8:00 a.m.: Renfe AVE 2080 leaves on the same path.
  3. 8:30 a.m.: LZB fails; six trains halt on 63 kilometres of line.
  4. 8:36 a.m.: Atocha authorises the AVE to resume at normal speed.
  5. 8:41 a.m.: The Iryo driver reports she is stopped at Urda’s entry signal.
  6. 8:53 a.m.: The AVE strikes the Iryo at kilometre 118.

Castilla-La Mancha president Emiliano García-Page said 24 of the dead were on the AVE and 44 on the Iryo. A 69th person died in hospital on October 29. Of 110 people admitted, 60 had been discharged by Thursday and 50 remained in hospital, 15 of them in a critical condition. About 1,300 rescuers worked the site on Wednesday. Among the dead was Fátima Báñez, employment minister from 2011 to 2018, who was in the last Iryo coach. The AVE driver, Antonio Acevedo, was also killed.

Adif Ordered the AVE to Resume at Normal Speed

Puente called the Atocha order inexplicable. With LZB down, trains were under lateral signalling, the old method of reading lineside lights. The Iryo had a red. The AVE’s path to the next station was occupied, a state the rulebook calls meta cero.

Under the rules that govern Spanish rail movements, that occupancy required running on sight at no more than 40 km/h, limited to what the driver could see. The order sent instead was to reconnect LZB and go at normal speed under BSL, the backup block.

The LZB is a thoroughly proven system, which can drop out, but that is what the guidelines and protocols are for.

Óscar Puente, Minister of Transport, Atocha press conference

Leaked radio captures the instruction to the AVE driver: disconnect and reconnect LZB and resume under BSL at normal speed. The Iryo driver called at 8:41 a.m. to say she was still at the red. Atocha told her to go when she could, and to call if she had problems. Puente said he did not know why she could not move.

WHAT THE ORDER DID

  • The protocol: Occupied track ahead means sight running, capped at 40 km/h.
  • The instruction: Reconnect LZB and proceed at normal speed.
  • The run: About 25 kilometres, with speed that Adif said reached 200 km/h.
  • The third train: Another Iryo driver given the same order demanded sight running and stayed out of the wreck.

That third driver, on a northbound Iryo that had left Seville at 6:47 a.m., was stopped about 50 kilometres from the crash. He refused normal speed and insisted on the 40 km/h cap. Had he accepted the order, his train would have been driving toward the wreckage. Guardia Civil officers questioned the Atocha controller who handled the Urda-Los Yébenes stretch. The Orgaz court is running the inquiry. Puente said the controller was experienced and had an assistant and a supervisor with him.

Why Madrid-Seville Still Runs on 1992 Signalling

Madrid-Seville was Spain’s first dedicated high-speed line, opened in 1992 for the Seville Expo. It still depends on LZB, a German cable-loop system that tells a train its permitted speed and can brake it if it closes on the train ahead. Most of the Spanish high-speed network uses ERTMS, the European standard that reads beacons instead of a track cable. The southern corridor never received it.

Adif Alta Velocidad approved the replacement file in November 2020. The tender was worth 131 million euros. In October 2021 the work went to Thales España for 93.83 million euros including tax, 28.4 percent below the estimate, a bid Adif itself labelled reckless and then accepted. The term was 52 months, which put completion in February 2026. Eight months after that date the new system is still not carrying trains. Puente, speaking in the Senate after the January crash, had listed the LZB swap as part of a 780 million euro renewal of the line.

Drivers’ union SEMAF said staff are working with degraded systems and that LZB should have been replaced long ago, adding that it failed on October 28 and had failed many times before. Puente said the change is happening because LZB has entered a phase of no further renewal, not because the kit is weak. José María Pérez Revenga, speaking for the Institute of Engineering, said that once LZB drops, drivers fall back to lineside signals “as in the old days,” and the control room must warn following trains to crawl.

José Trigueros, president of the Association of Civil Engineers, said a rear-end collision on high-speed track is more worrying than January’s crash at Adamuz, because the protection is supposed to make it impossible for two trains to share a block. “What happens, that we cannot trust our automated safety systems, and that they can be in human hands?” he said.

46 Dead in January, Then 69 in October

On January 18, an Iryo train from Málaga to Madrid derailed at Adamuz in Córdoba province. Its rear cars crossed into the path of a Renfe Alvia running the other way toward Huelva. That crash killed 46 people, including the Alvia driver, and injured hundreds. CIAF, the rail accident commission, has focused on a faulty weld and a broken rail. Train drivers’ union SEMAF had already written to Adif about wear on that stretch.

Nine months and 10 days later, the same two operators met again on the same Madrid-Andalusia corridor. Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez, who went to the Urda site, said two high-speed accidents in one year were unacceptable for Spain and that safety would be reinforced if that was what it took to restore confidence. He declared three days of official mourning, as he had in January.

ADAMUZ AND URDA

Crash Adamuz, Jan 18 Urda, Oct 28
Place Córdoba, Madrid-Seville line Toledo, kilometre 118
Trains Iryo 6189 and Renfe Alvia 2384 Iryo 6076 and Renfe AVE 2080
Type Derailment, then head-on Rear-end into a stopped train
Deaths 46 69
Working theory Broken rail, faulty weld LZB outage, then a normal-speed order

Public broadcaster RTVE counted 115 rail deaths in 2026 from the two crashes, more than in 2013, the year an Alvia derailed at Santiago de Compostela and killed 79 people. Santiago was on a conventional curve at the end of a high-speed run. Urda happened on dedicated high-speed track. Spain’s railway safety agency has recorded a rise in accidents, including derailments and collisions, from 45 in 2016 to 57 in 2024 and 69 in 2025.

Competition Put More Trains on the Same Rails

Spain opened commercial passenger rail to competition at the end of 2020, under an EU deadline. Ouigo, the low-cost arm of France’s SNCF, started Madrid-Barcelona on May 11, 2021. Iryo, a venture of Trenitalia, Air Nostrum and Globalvia, followed in November 2022 and became the first private operator on the southern corridor after March 30, 2023. From January 2025, three companies and four brands (AVE, Avlo, Iryo, Ouigo) have run the three busiest corridors.

The National Commission on Markets and Competition counted 44.5 million high-speed passengers in 2025, 12 percent more than the year before and double the 2019 total. High-speed circulations rose from under 40,000 in 2020 to 106,282 trains in 2024. Network use, measured in train-kilometres, grew 42 percent between 2019 and 2024, and 28 percent on the Madrid-South corridor where both crashes occurred. Spain has 3,324 kilometres of high-speed line, the most in Europe.

Riders paid less. The watchdog found ticket prices fell about 40 percent in real terms against 2019, and by half on Madrid-Valencia. The average Madrid-Seville fare in 2025 was 38.41 euros. Ouigo’s arrival on the southern routes in January 2025 cut prices another 12 percent that year. Iryo holds 27 to 28 percent of the Andalusia routes. Renfe’s national share has dropped almost 30 points, to 72 percent.

What did not multiply was the number of infrastructure managers. Adif still owns the track, the signals and the Atocha desk that issues movement authorities when the computers fail. More trains at tighter intervals mean more work for that desk, and more strain on a line whose protection system was already in a no-renewal phase. Delays on the high-speed network have tripled since the market opened, and daily trains on the main corridors have risen by about 45 percent.

No Time Given for a Southern Restart

Adif said it had interrupted high-speed traffic between Madrid and Andalusia after the rear-end collision at kilometre 118. Trains are still running on the high-speed sections between Madrid and Toledo and between Málaga and Seville. The manager opened help desks at Madrid Puerta de Atocha, Seville Santa Justa, Córdoba and Málaga.

Iryo cancelled every service from Atocha onto the southern corridor and gave no time for a restart. Ouigo, coordinating with Adif, cancelled all of its Madrid-Andalusia trains. Renfe is offering free changes and cancellations and said it would run replacement transport from October 30. Interrail warned that all high-speed trains on the Madrid-Andalusia line were suspended, including services to Ciudad Real, Córdoba and Seville.

WHO STOPPED RUNNING SOUTH

  • Renfe: High-speed Madrid-Andalusia services halted; free changes and an alternative plan from October 30.
  • Iryo: All Atocha departures on the southern corridor cancelled, with no estimated restart.
  • Ouigo: All Madrid-Andalusia trains cancelled in step with Adif.
  • Open sections: Madrid-Toledo and Málaga-Seville high-speed still running.

The UK Foreign Office warned of significant disruption and told travellers to check with the operators before going to a station. For help on affected passengers it listed Renfe on +34 900 10 10 20. British nationals caught in the crash can call the embassy or consulate on +34 91 714 6300.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The dead: Castilla-La Mancha’s official count on October 29 is 69.
  • The order: Atocha authorised normal speed at 8:36 a.m. with a train still on the line.
  • The system: LZB dropped at 8:30 a.m.; ERTMS is not yet in service on this line.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • A final toll: Rescue teams were still matching DNA to remains in the cars on Thursday.
  • Why she stayed: Puente said he did not know why the Iryo could not move after the second call.
  • A restart date: Iryo has given none, and Adif has not said when the corridor will reopen.

Carlos Bertomeu, Iryo’s president, said the crash should never have happened and that a regulated sector would now have to establish what went wrong so it does not happen again. Renfe said its train moved as instructed and that the exact sequence would have to be set by the investigation. Identification work continues at Orgaz. The signalling that was supposed to retire this year is still the system in the ground.

Harry is the editor of RTD JOURNAL, an independent publication that he owns, and ten years of journalism, first as a reporter, now as an editor, have left him with a habit of reading the documents other people skip. Annual reports are read to the footnotes, court filings to the exhibits, government releases to the methodology section, because that is where the numbers that matter usually sit. Each figure that reaches the page is checked against the document it came from, and claims that cannot be tied to a primary source are left out. That approach runs across the site's ten sections, written for an international readership: news, business and technology on one side, science, sports, entertainment, travel, lifestyle, gaming and auto on the other, all held to the same standard of evidence. A mistake, once found, is fixed on the article with a dated note that explains the change, as the site's public corrections policy requires. Readers can reach him with documents, questions or corrections at support@rtdjournal.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending